| Platinum | Step Soup and Sandwich |
| Gold | Golden Rooster Deli |
| Silver | Flight Cheese Shop |
| Bronze | Glenburnie Grocery |
| Top Pick | Barriefield Meat Market |
| Top Pick | Bob's Butcher Shop |
| Top Pick | Farm Boy |
| Top Pick | Homestyle Deli |
| Top Pick | Old Farm Fine Foods |
| Top Pick | Pan Chancho Bakery & Café |