| Platinum | Dianne's Fish Shack & Smokehouse |
| Platinum | Red Lobster |
| Gold | The Rose & Crown Restaurant |
| Silver | Mike Mundell's Surf & Turf Stores |
| Bronze | Carmelindas |
| Top Pick | Lobster Trap Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mayla |
| Top Pick | The Boathouse |
| Top Pick | Tommy's Diner |
| Top Pick | Union Kitchen + Cocktails |